HFM vs Rakuten FX

Results for the entity you would contract with from Japan. Licence, fund protection and regulator warnings, compared from public information.

Summary

If you apply from Japan, HFM contracts you with HF Markets (SV) Ltd (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines) and Rakuten FX with Rakuten Securities, Inc. (Japan).

Scores are HFM 63 and Rakuten FX 88 out of 100; Rakuten FX is 25 points higher. The two differ in: Licence, Fund protection, Years in business, Regulator warnings, Residents of Japan, Score breakdown.

Where they differ

  • Licence: Licensing country and strictness of review: HFM: Licence not confirmed. Rakuten FX: Japan (Strict review). Licence points (out of 40): HFM 11, Rakuten FX 40.
  • Fund protection: Verification and points (out of 20): HFM: 15 points (2 of 3 items verified). Rakuten FX: 8 points (1 of 3 items verified).
  • Years in business: HFM: 16 years. Rakuten FX: 27 years.
  • Regulator warnings: HFM: Regulator warning: Financial Services Agency (FSA). Rakuten FX: Registered with the Japan FSA.
  • Residents of Japan: HFM: Treatment of Japan residents not confirmed. Rakuten FX: Accepts applications from Japan.
  • Score breakdown: licence (out of 40): HFM 11, Rakuten FX 40; fund protection (out of 20): HFM 15, Rakuten FX 8; disclosure (out of 15): HFM 12, Rakuten FX 15.

Comparison table

HFM (HotForex)
→ HF Markets (SV) Ltd
▲ Regulator warning: Financial Services Agency (FSA)
63Fair
Rakuten FX (Rakuten Securities)
→ Rakuten Securities, Inc.
No regulator warning
88High
Regulator warnings
Regulator warning: Financial Services Agency (FSA)
No warning
Licence
Saint Vincent and the Grenadines (Lenient review)
Japan (Strict review)
Fund protection
15 / 20 points
8 / 20 points
Years in business
16 years
27 years
Licence (40)
11
40
Fund protection (20)
15
8
Years in business (15)
15
15
Disclosure (15)
12
15
Sanctions (10)
10
10
Last checked
2026-11-16
2026-11-16

Rows with a mark to the left of the label differ between the two.

How scores are set

Broker pages

More comparisons

HFM

Rakuten FX

All comparisonsAdd other brokers to compare