IC Markets vs Vantage

Results for the entity you would contract with from Japan. Licence, fund protection and regulator warnings, compared from public information.

Summary

If you apply from Japan, IC Markets contracts you with Raw Trading Ltd (Seychelles). The entity for Japan is not identified for Vantage, so the result is for its international entity, Vantage Global Limited (Vanuatu).

Scores are IC Markets 77 and Vantage 57 out of 100; IC Markets is 20 points higher. The two differ in: Licence, Fund protection, Residents of Japan, Score breakdown.

Where they differ

  • Licence: Licensing country and strictness of review: IC Markets: Seychelles (Lenient review). Vantage: Vanuatu (Lenient review). Licence points (out of 40): IC Markets 32, Vantage 32.
  • Fund protection: Verification and points (out of 20): IC Markets: 8 points (1 of 3 items verified). Vantage: not verified.
  • Residents of Japan: IC Markets: Accepts applications from Japan. Vantage: Treatment of Japan residents not confirmed.
  • Score breakdown: fund protection (out of 20): IC Markets 8, Vantage 0; disclosure (out of 15): IC Markets 12, Vantage 0.

Same on both: Years in business, Regulator warnings

Comparison table

IC Markets
→ Raw Trading Ltd
▲ Regulator warning: Financial Services Agency (FSA)
77High
Vantage
→ Vantage Global Limited
▲ Regulator warning: Financial Services Agency (FSA)
57Fair
Regulator warnings
Regulator warning: Financial Services Agency (FSA)
Regulator warning: Financial Services Agency (FSA)
Licence
Seychelles (Lenient review)
Vanuatu (Lenient review)
Fund protection
8 / 20 points
Not verified
Years in business
17 years
17 years
Licence (40)
32
32
Fund protection (20)
8
0
Years in business (15)
15
15
Disclosure (15)
12
0
Sanctions (10)
10
10
Last checked
2026-11-16
2026-11-16

Rows with a mark to the left of the label differ between the two.

How scores are set

Broker pages

More comparisons

IC Markets

Vantage

All comparisonsAdd other brokers to compare