Scoring method

The safety score is out of 100 and uses only information anyone can verify, such as regulator records. Every rule is written on this page.

0〜49 pts
Use caution

Many items could not be verified, or the broker holds only a licence from a lenient country.

50〜79 pts
Fair

Licensed, but with gaps in fund protection or disclosure.

80〜100 pts
High

Holds a licence from a strict country, and fund protection has been verified.

A high score is not a guarantee of safety. Use it as one of the checks before you open an account.

Five items and how points are given

40

Licence

Which country grants the broker its licence. We confirm a licence by its listing in the regulator's official register. Where a regulator does not publish licence numbers in its register, we confirm that the company name is listed and show the number as published by the broker.

Pick the one that applies
40Licence from a strict country (Japan, the UK, Australia, the US, etc.)
28Licence from a standard country (EU states such as Cyprus, Dubai, South Africa)
14Licence from a lenient country (Seychelles, Mauritius, Vanuatu, etc.)
0No licence could be confirmed
20

Fund protection

Whether your deposit would come back if the company failed.

Add up what has been verified
8Client money is held separately from company funds
7A government or similar compensation scheme exists if the company fails
5The broker states officially that losses cannot exceed your deposit
15

Years in business

How long since the company was founded.

Based on the number of years
1.51.5 points per year since founding (maximum at 10 years)
15

Disclosure

Whether company information is open to everyone.

Add up what has been verified
5Publishes company name, registration number and address
5Publishes terms of use and key risk notices
5Publishes externally audited financial statements
10

Sanctions

Whether the licensing country has sanctioned the broker in the past five years. We judge this within the range of regulator announcements we could check. Several sanctions are added up and deducted (the score never goes below 0).

Start from 10 and deduct for sanctions (only those since November 2021)
10No sanction found
−3Fined
−6Licence temporarily suspended
−10Licence revoked

Verification stages: verified and auto-checked

Brokers worldwide are listed whether or not you can apply from Japan. Brokers a person has verified and brokers listed automatically from regulator data are clearly separated.

Verified

A person has read official regulator and broker documents and checked the five items above. Sources and check dates are listed item by item.

Auto-checked

These are listed mechanically from data published by a regulator. At present they come from (1) the list of Cyprus Investment Firms (CIFs) published by the Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC), active firms only, and (2) the licensee dataset of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC): companies that may deal as principal in foreign exchange and OTC derivatives for retail clients and also hold a market-making authorisation. For ASIC, banks, currency exchangers, remittance and payment firms and fund managers are removed by name and category. The CySEC list does not show the products offered, so whether a firm offers FX or CFDs is shown as unverified (suspended firms, firms that asked to give up their licence, and pending registrations are not listed). The brand name is unknown, so the legal name is shown.

How auto-checked scores are given (maximum 55 for ASIC, 28 for CySEC)

28〜40Licence: listed in the regulator's official list. ASIC (Australia, a strict country) gives 40 points; CySEC (Cyprus, standard review) gives 28
0〜15Years in business: for ASIC, 1.5 points per year from the licence start date (maximum 15), counted from the licence start and not from the company founding. The CySEC list has no authorisation date and it is not confirmed that the last two digits of the licence number are the year, so it is scored 0 (unverified)
0Fund protection and disclosure: not verified yet, so 0. Cyprus Investment Firms must join the Investor Compensation Fund (ICF), but this has not been checked for each firm, so no points are given (only what is verified is added)
0Sanctions: the ASIC dataset lists only currently valid licences and does not show revocations or suspensions, and the CySEC list has no sanction records. We do not treat this as "no sanction found"; it is unverified and scored 0

For auto-checked brokers, the official site and whether residents of Japan are accepted have not been checked either. Once a person re-reads the documents, a broker moves to "verified".

What is not in the score

Japan FSA warnings

Not counted in the score. They are always shown at the top of the result, so a high score never hides them.

Reviews

We do not publish reviews yet. When we do, they will be shown as a separate score, never part of the safety score.

Treatment of residents of Japan

Whether a broker accepts residents of Japan, and which company would serve them, is shown as information and not scored. If the company for applicants from Japan cannot be identified from official documents, the score uses the broker's international entity and the page says so.

Fees and bonuses

Low fees and big bonuses depend on personal preference, so they are not scored.

Unconfirmed items score 0

Only items confirmed in official regulator or broker documents are scored. Items we could not confirm are scored 0, not assumed.

Brokers that exclude residents of Japan

Some brokers state on their official site that they do not serve residents of Japan. If a Japanese-language site or the terms name an operating company, we score using that company and say so at the top of the broker page.

Sources and check dates

Each broker page lists, item by item, the URL of the document behind the score and the date we checked it. Things may have changed after the check date.

How countries are grouped

Strict countries (40 pts)
Japan, the United Kingdom, Australia, the United States
Standard countries (28 pts)
Cyprus, Malta, Ireland, Germany, France, the Netherlands, Czechia, Dubai (UAE), South Africa
Lenient countries (14 pts)
Seychelles, Mauritius, Vanuatu, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, the Bahamas, Belize, the British Virgin Islands, the Cayman Islands, Labuan (Malaysia), Comoros, Saint Lucia

Sources and credits

  • Source: Financial Services Agency of Japan, "Names of persons conducting financial instruments business without registration" (https://www.fsa.go.jp/ordinary/chuui/mutouroku.html), edited by the site. A firm not on the list is not necessarily registered.(fsa.go.jp). Retrieved 2026-11-16.
  • Source: Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), AFS Licensee Dataset, data.gov.au, licensed under CC BY 3.0 AU. Modified from the original. Retrieved 2026-11-16. ASIC does not endorse or guarantee this content.
  • Source: Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC), "Investment Firms (Cypriot)" (list as of 2026-05-04). Reused with attribution under CySEC's conditions of re-use. CySEC does not endorse or guarantee this content.(cysec.gov.cy)
Look up a broker